RecipesRumSeasonal Papa’s Pumpkin Pie By Ashley Bray - October 30, 2017 Ingredients: 1 3/4 oz. Don Papa Rum 1/2 oz. Pumpkin puree 1/2 oz. Pumpkin spice syrup Two dashes of orange bitters 3/4 oz. Lime juice Mint sprig and icing sugar Directions: Shake ingredients together & serve! Courtesy of Don Papa Rum.